Showing posts with label Religious education in English schools - non-statutory guidance 2009. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Religious education in English schools - non-statutory guidance 2009. Show all posts

Saturday, October 24, 2009

New Guidance on Religious Education

source: Edlines Summer 2009


The Government has issued new draft guidance on the teaching of Religious Education (RE) in English schools for public consultation (ending on 24 July). The guidance is intended to replace that issued in 1994 (Circular 1/94) which was widely believed, even at the time, to represent very poor advice on RE. The BHA was represented on the steering group that helped to produce the new draft and in many ways we believe it represents a considerable advance on previous guidance.

However, it fails to address our two principal concerns in RE: that RE should be the study of both religious and non-religious beliefs; that humanists should have the same right to be full members of the local committees writing and overseeing RE syllabuses as religious people have. More...

Sunday, October 18, 2009

BHA Response to Consultation on draft ‘Religious Education in English schools: non-statutory guidance 2009’

my comments on non-statutory guidelines published January 2010 are in red.
A: Introduction
  • References of ‘religions’ in primary legislation should become ‘religions and beliefs’
    • the majority of references to 'religion' do not include 'and beliefs'.
  • local syllabuses are not the best way of delivering good RE.
    • they give rise to patchy quality, uneven provision, and a postcode lottery. 
    • they prevent progression for pupils who may move from local authority to local authority. 
    • no comment
  • We are in favour of a national entitlement to a subject called ‘Religions and Beliefs’
    • which deals with religious and non-religious beliefs in a balanced manner 
    • that takes the place of local determination.
    • no comments
  • We welcome that the new guidance
    • generally uses the language of ‘religions and beliefs’, which includes Humanism 
    • religion(s) and / or belief(s) are mentioned more than 30 times
    • restates again the government’s view that RE should entail
      • not a confessional induction into any one religion or belief, nor religion generally, 
      • but a genuinely educational study of religious and non-religious beliefs about questions of importance, 
        • in the process of which young people will develop their own responses to these questions. 
      • not included
    B: Humanism and Humanists – concerns with present guidance
    • The content of the curriculum 
      • the inclusion of Humanism in RE remains vague and patchy. 
      • ditto
      • Although the word Humanism at least receives a mention in many syllabuses, the required teaching usually remains at a minimal level. . 
    • The new guidance should explicitly state 
      • that the subject matter for RE is the principal religions and beliefs represented in Great Britain
      • not stated
      • that membership of the relevant group or committee on SACREs and ASCs respectively should be representative of the principal religious and belief traditions in the area. 
      • not stated
      • what is meant by ‘belief’ in this context
        • We set out below further details of how this should be done.
        • not stated
    • Eligibility of Humanists for full membership of SACREs and ASCs 
      • the new guidance recommends co-opted, non-voting membership of SACREs for humanists and no membership at all of Agreed Syllabus Conferences 
      • since government is recommending that Humanism be included in the syllabus, a prohibition on humanists being involved in deciding what will be said about them and their beliefs (when religious representatives are included) is a gross inequality.
      • When Circular 1/94 was issued, 
        • most humanists who had been full members of existing SACREs were demoted to non-voting, co-opted membership, if they were retained at all
          • Only two SACREs: Oxford and Westminster, in defiance of the guidance, chose to keep their humanists as full members of SACRE group A and ASC committee A. 
        • Since 1994, some co-opted humanists have been chairs and vice chairs of SACREs. 
        • In SACREs of good will, the position of humanists has not been as bad in practice as circular 1/94 mandated in theory. 
        • The experience of other humanists, however, (and this is the case for most) has been that circular 1/94 makes SACREs and ASCs feel unable to appoint humanists as members of SACREs and ASCs, 
          • and gives cover to those who, for reasons of prejudice, do not wish to do so. 
        • Crucially, even where humanists have been able to be co-opted members of SACREs, they have still been prevented from being members of ASCs and so actually involved (as their religious colleagues are) in the writing of syllabuses. 
        • On other SACREs humanists have been made to feel unwelcome and present only on sufferance. 
    • We are concerned that this situation will not be resolved by the draft guidance and that by stopping short of recommending full membership of SACREs and ASCs for humanists, it may actually reverse the progress made in some areas. 
      • Oxford and Westminster were the only SACREs that chose to retain their humanists as full members in 1994, 
        • at least seven further SACREs who have restored full group/committee A membership to humanists since 1998
          •  Brent, Suffolk, Portsmouth, Northumberland, Harrow, Ealing and Camden. 
            • In the case of Brent, Portsmouth, and Suffolk this was explicitly in light of the Human Rights Act and Equality Act 2006. 
    • The new guidance should state explicitly that 
      • representatives of non-religious beliefs (worldviews or lifestances) such as Humanism are equally eligible with those of religions for membership of the group or committee of SACREs and ASCs, 
      • not stated
        • so giving humanists the right to be full members alongside the religious representatives.
    • The law 
      • the extension of the syllabus to include Humanism and of the membership of SACREs and ASCs to include humanists is what the law demands. 
      • The present draft guidance fails to fulfil the DCSF’s obligations under the Human Rights Act sections 3 and 6 and the Equality Act 2006 section 52. 
        • references to ‘religions’ in the present law on RE should be read as references to ‘religions or beliefs’ in the new guidance. 
        • some mentions of 'religions or beliefs'
        • ‘principal religions’ must be read as ‘principal religions or beliefs’ so that Humanism is made very clearly a wholly legitimate worldview for study
        • not stated
        • references to membership of SACREs and ASCs, ‘religions’ must be read as ‘religions or beliefs’, giving humanists the right to be full members alongside the religious representatives.
        • not stated
    C: Comments on the draft guidance
    to follow in a later post

    Consultation on New Guidance for Religious Education in England: Take Action!


    Read: Religious education in English schools: Non‑statutory guidance 2009

    Take ActionWhat is the issue?

    On 30th April, the Department for Children, Schools and Families (DCSF) issued new draft guidance on the teaching of Religious Education (RE) in English schools for public consultation, which ended on 24th July.

    The guidance is intended to replace that issued in 1994 (Circular 1/94) which was widely believed, even at the time, to represent very poor advice on RE. The BHA was represented on the steering group that helped to produce the new draft, and we welcome the fact that, in many ways, it is an advance on the previous guidance, but it fails to address our two principal concerns in RE:
    • that RE should be the study of both religious and non-religious beliefs;
    • that humanists should have the same right to be full members of the local committees writing and overseeing RE syllabuses as religious people have.

    What do we want?

    Take Action on RE



    • We want the government to use the Human Rights Act to make it explicit that references to ‘religion’ in the present law on RE should be read as references to ‘religion or belief’. 


    • This would mean that non-religious philosophies such as Humanism would be included by right in the subject, rather than just be recommendation as present. 


    • In particular, we want the references to the content of RE as being about ‘principal religions’ to be read as ‘principal religions or beliefs’ 


    • and the eligibility for full membership of Standing Advisory Councils for RE (SACREs – the local committees that oversee RE) and Agreed Syllabus Conferences (ASCs – the local committees that set the RE syllabus) as a representatives of ‘religions’ to be read as ‘religions or beliefs’, giving humanists the explicit right to be full members alongside the religious representatives.

    • The phrase ‘religion or belief’ is taken from the language of the Human Rights Act and it includes non-religious beliefs such as Humanism. 

    The phrase ‘religion or belief’ is already used in the government’s national framework for RE (2004) and in the RE section of the secondary curriculum (2007) as well as in the proposed new primary curriculum (2009). In those places, it is made clear that it includes Humanism.


    • It is very important that this should be the case in the new guidance, and that it should be made clear that this is the interpretation that should be given to the law on RE in light of the Human Rights Act, 


    which forbids discrimination on grounds of religion or belief by public authorities and in section 3 requires existing legislation to be 'read and given effect in a way which is compatible with the Convention rights'.

    The BHA's own Director of Education and Public Affairs, Andrew Copson, has recently given a recorded interview about the BHA's position on RE to Teachers TV, an organisation which supports the professional development of teachers and others working in schools.

    What can you do?

    Action Point 1
    Although the public consultation on the proposed new RE guidance has now closed, there is still scope to petition the government. It is not too late to email your MP, using the BHA’s easy online facility and urge him or her to make your views known to the government and support changing the guidance.
    Action Point 2
    You can email your local councillor and ask that they get your council to support the changes to the RE guidance we are looking for and then make its view known to the government. You can also make a direct request to the councillor who holds the education portfolio. They are often known as the Portfolio Holder for Children & Young People or Children’s Services – your council website or general inquires line should provide you with their details.
    Action Point 3
    If you are a teacher, you could explore the possibility of your school contacting the Department for Children, Schools and Families urging the changes we are looking for.

    Action Point 4
    If you are a teacher of RE, or otherwise involved in RE as a professional you can contact the National Association of Teachers of RE or Association of RE Inspectors Advisers and Consultants (AREIAC) and urge them to contact the government supporting the changes we are seeking.
    Action Point 5
    If you are a member of a SACRE, whether as a humanist or not, you can urge your SACRE or local authority to contact the government asking that they support the changes we are seeking.
    You could contact your local SACRE even if you are not involved, to find out what position they and your local authority are taking on these issues. There is a partial list of SACREs online.
    Action Point 6
    If you are a member of a political party, you can write to the education contact or spokesperson of your party to urge them to support the changes we are seeking. For Labour, this is Rt Hon. Ed Balls MP,  for Conservatives this is Michael Gove MP, for Liberal Democrats this is David Laws MP.
    Please copy any submissions you make or correspondence you enter into on this subject to Paul Pettinger at the BHA by email or by post to British Humanist Association, 1 Gower Street, London WC1E 6HD.

    Related documents